The vocal portions of the Web that care about such things seem to have already made up their minds about Dart, the new web programming language from Google. My opinion of it has been flipping between intrigue and tedium.
Origins of Dart at Google
So they did just that. Sort of.
Dear Google, Public Relations != Developer Relations
Google suffers from NIH Syndrome: it does not take from the outside world, preferring to build its tools from scratch, and anything it produces it does so mainly for consumption by the thousands of people it employs (this manifests itself in things like their approach to Platform development, too). Don’t let the odd open-sourced project fool you.
In the case of Dart (not the first Google-made langauge) they may have hyped up its announcement, but they clearly have no intention of letting programmers — the only people who care — actually experiment with the new language yet. When you go to Dart’s code repository, there is little effort made to make it simple for you build and use anything.
Maybe Dart is just not ready for too much public airing, but that means they should have left its unveiling until it was. Google is not providing a pre-built compiler or VM binary for Dart, and their build instructions are just about tedious enough that I’d rather not waste my time. If
git clone and
make install are good enough for many a large project, why am I being instructed to install and use a Google-specific tool to merely fetch code?! No thanks.
What’s Dart Like?
Key Language Features
This is one of the more baffling features for me. You could write Dart code without any consideration for variable types, but you could also annotate your variables with types, like String or any class you’ve defined. The baffling nature of this is that the annotation is just that, an annotation: it makes no difference to how your code works, other than the compiler giving you a warning if you’ve misused the variable (e.g. tried to assign a number to a String variable). The code will still compile and run.
Structure and isolation
In the language specification, there is some detail about the concurrency model of Dart, which involves these isolates behaving like actors which perform local computation and then communicate via message-passing. I didn’t spend much time trying to understand these, but this (rather negative) write-up has an explanation.
Why you won’t use Dart
Firstly, there is obviously no practical implementation for developing or deploying Dart code, so don’t waste your time on it yet. Even the Google Chrome team aren’t 100% on whether and when they will implement a Dart runtime, let alone other browser vendors.